Psychology

You are logged in as xxxx. Logout

Question

This question has been answered by 103 people and has an average rating of 3.57 (based on 83 ratings)

As I am walking to my PSYC 101 final exam, a woman, holding her ipod,  stops me on the street and asks me "where is the McGill metro stop?". 

While looking at my phone, to make sure I am giving her the right information, I tell her very clearly and audibly that it is down the street. 

She answers that she doesn't hear what I am saying. I therefore assume that she  ____________(1). 

I therefore write the information onto my phone so that she can read it. Unfortunately, she again seems to be unable to understand, as she also probably has ___________(2). 

What can I do so that she will get the info? (3) 

Alternatives

The contributor suggests D is the correct option
Option Alternative First
answers
Confirmed
answers
A

(1) has Wernicke's aphasia - due to damage in Wernicke's area

(2) Pure alexia - due to damage in the VWFA

(3) Repeat what I said louder - she just didn't hear me the first time around. 

2 (1.94%)

0 (0.00%)

B

(1) has Transcortical sensory aphasia - due to damage in posterior language area

(2) Pure dyslexia - due to damage in the VWFA

(3) Look at her while I repeat my sentence. She will be able to read my lips.

10 (9.71%)

0 (0.00%)

C

(1) is deaf. 

(2) Pure dyslexia - due to damage in her primary visual cortex

(3) Repeat what I said louder - she just didn't hear me the first time around.

3 (2.91%)

0 (0.00%)

D

(1) has Pure word deafness - due to damage in Wernicke's area

(2) Pure alexia - due to damage in the VWFA 

(3) Look at her while I repeat my sentence. She will be able to read my lips.

77 (74.76%)

32 (100.00%)

E

(1) has Pure word deafness - due to damage in the posterior language area

(2) Pure alexia - due to damage in her visual association cortex

(3) Spell out the information letter by letter

11 (10.68%)

0 (0.00%)

Explanation

The following explanation has been provided relating to this question:

(1) - The woman is clearly not deaf as she has an ipod so was listening to music.

She says that she doesn't hear what I am saying because she has pure word deafness. This is a problem due to damage in Wernicke's area, the area responsible for recognizing words. 

 

(2) - pure alexia (and not pure dyslexia) is due to damage in the VWFA

 

(3) - people with pure word deafness can read on your lips

Topics

The following topics have been indicated as being relevant to this question:

Aphasia, Chapter 13

Administrator comment

As an administrator, you can choose to write a comment about this question that will be visible to all students. This comment will appear above all student comments and will be clearly highlighted.

Add administrator comment

Comments

There are 14 comments for this question (12 top-level comments and 2 replies) As an administrator for this course, you can write comments about this question. Any comments you write will appear just like student comments. If you would like to write a special comment that is labelled as an "Administrator comment", please use the option above.
Written: 2:01pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 3999 points and 12 badges

Nice question! Tricky and you have to think about it, but very interesting! 

Reply to this comment
Written: 1:15pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 6107 points and 18 badges

This is a good question for testing understanding, but it is unlikely that a person would have both pure word deafness and pure alexia without having other issues that relate to speech.

 Written: 2:54pm, 17 DecReply written by question author
 

Yes good point!

  Add a reply to this comment
Written: 11:31am, 17 DecAuthor has: 6696 points and 20 badges

Great question! A really creative way to integrate a lot of info from chapter 13, good explanation too :)

Reply to this comment
Written: 11:44am, 17 DecAuthor has: 5792 points and 20 badges

I liked this question!! It definitely took me some time to think it all through!

Reply to this comment
Written: 1:59pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 5861 points and 23 badges

Really great question! You integrate a lot of information, all in a fun scenario. Good luck on the final!

 Written: 2:54pm, 17 DecReply written by question author
 

Thank you, you too!

  Add a reply to this comment
Written: 4:48pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 6036 points and 15 badges

this is a great question as in combines several aspects of multiple disorders in one -- good work!

Reply to this comment
Written: 5:11pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 3699 points and 13 badges

This is a great question! Really makes you reflect on the course material. 

Reply to this comment
Written: 8:47pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 5630 points and 16 badges

This question really had me thinking, good one!

Reply to this comment
Written: 9:41pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 4546 points and 18 badges

A very good question to make one think about the material while interacting with it!

Reply to this comment
Written: 10:52pm, 17 DecAuthor has: 3489 points and 13 badges

Really clever and creative question with good answer choices!

Reply to this comment

<< Prev | 1-10 | 11-12 | Next >>
(Displaying 1 - 10 of 12)

Write a new comment

Edit this question

If you edit the question, this current version will be archived and a new version of the question will be created (this new version will still appear as being authored by the original author, however all ratings, comments and responses will be reset).

Edit this question

Delete this question

If you feel this question is inappropriate for this course, you can delete it from the system by pressing the button below. All associated ratings and feedback comments will also be deleted if you choose to remove this question.